[b]Your very right Indeed Executor.. I'm One step behind you as always..[/b] [b]I'm Getting dizzy with the in's and out of other member, Like a bunch of kids playing around.. Letter B please...[/b] [b]Hope they'll stick to the one Group they know whats best for them...[/b]

Last edited by BwizetT (2008-08-18 09:21:19)

I agree with this suggestion as well. I like suggestion 'B'. Like aries said, in Rockstars, also, the rule is that if you leave our group you must PM the leader, however, it seems that rule is ignored most of the time. Good suggestion, bro Jie. I hope this will be implemented one day.

even though,i don't have an e-group., i humbly support kuya jie's statement.,the scenario b., that is to solve the issue on members who don't lay down their reasons for leaving a certain group.,xD i know the fellow members would feel about someone leaving their group., they would start thinking like "whoaa..what's wrong with our group?" so reasons are really important.,that way,the group could even improve thru those reasons.,xD like, the reason is.."oh, the discussion was boring to me always.,xD" s, the members could try to improve their group thru lively discussions. .,am i making a sense? well, i have said what is on my mind.,xD

[b]This is a good suggestion Executor ^^ I prefer scenario B..It would really be helpful for all egroups if that feature would be implemented.. I agree with Sis Duch too that some members just join groups to snoop around and see what's going on and all that.. I've been patient about this issue and been keeping my opinions to myself regarding that...but lately i guess i just have to express my concerns about the whole thing...Members may have the right to leave and join any group of their choice but i guess we do have the right to be informed too.. [/b]

^ second the motion one of my reasons why i support this is because, by stating the reason why you leave the group, it can also help the group in a way, like you left because of some problems. if you inform them, at least they can find a way to improve the group.

well i agree also,. and i know what it feels liek when teh members of teh e-group just [i]come and go,.[/i] [i]errr....[/i] one day or another., i will just gonna found out myself,. that,. he/she already left,. [i]very sad[/i] but i dun blame them if they want to join others,. all i want is to be [i]informed properly,[/i]. so that not only me and that person knew that left teh group well also teh other groupmates,. i really agree on to this,.. especially on [b]scenario b[/b]

[quote=jieduck]scenario B: - if a member wishes to press the "leave group" button, a prompt box will appear in which he/she will state the reason of quiting the group, and the message in that "reason box" will be directly sent to the inbox of the group leader.[/quote] [color=#FF33cc]Though i don't have a group here, i have my own group outside. and I do agree with kuya jie's idea. I certainly find other members who just join a group and taking them for granted, some join only because someone they know is inside the group, some just wanted to know what's inside the group, some join just as to say that they're a member of the group.[/color] [quote=bhebhiej]To add to this suggestion, also, maybe we could make it harder to join the eGroups, some kind of requirement that requires the member who wants to join to have to go out of his/her way to become a member, simply to see what kind of dedication they intend to give to their respective group.[/quote] [color=#FF33cc] I totally agree with you here jesse, "a thing that was gotten with hardship are the things are so hard to loose". I just thought that if a member exerted a lot of effort before he was accepted into a group, and did what he was asked to do to be accepted,then I guess he really is determined to join the group..[/color]

I prefer Scenario B than A. A prompt-box will appear when member click the Leave Button. And member will give his/her reason why he/she left the group. So other members won't be shocked. ;_; And oh.. it'll be good also when members want to join a Private group, a prompt-box will appear, just like what I saw on other forum, if you want to join a group, you have to give clear reason on a small box then wait for approval. Leaders can see the pending approval requests' with their reason and discuss with other members about them. I'll try to tell admin about this suggestion if it's possible or not.

Last edited by Jirichi Ryunashira (2008-09-22 18:28:51)

the scenario b is better for me... i agree with all of yah... i hope admin would consider this too...