[quote=LiLbLuEaNgEl]cuz all simons comment to cook at the final is negative[/quote] Nope, Simon called Cook's first song in the finale PHENOMENAL actually. [quote=losher29]and david archuleta seems a lil bit gayish *peace*[/quote] It's because of how he moves sometimes when singing (esp. when he sang "with you"). *peace too* for me, i think Archie suits the title more than Cook. but Cook is a better recording artist actually. well i'm sure the two of them will be making big in the music industry. it doesn't really matter who won or who's not. they both have the talent so they're both winners. and also, i just think it's fair. Archie not good with rock, Cook doesn't suit ballad.